Showing posts with label animal rights. Show all posts
Showing posts with label animal rights. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 6, 2017

Doesn't

Doesn't, possibly, every living creature have the right not to feel like a ghost?


Monday, February 13, 2017

Disturbing

I admire so much of what P.E.T.A. does.

I love to hear Ingrid Newkirk speak about the existential plight we share with animals.

But the totally unnecessary animal killing P.E.T.A. does boggles my mind and horrifies me.

Nathan J. Winograd explains.

Now, why on earth would you choose murder over sterilization for stray cats, which has demonstrated success? I'm very proud of my community for the truly successful program we have here that has drastically limited our wild cat population in an ethical manner. Other communities even look to ours when setting up their own programs along these lines. They have seen that it works and that it saves the community money. It's actually much more cost-effective than euthanasia.

This isn't the first time I read horror stories like this about P.E.T.A.. I remember reading about volunteers driving around and rounding up wild cats and killing them. I can't see any defense for this and I see it as a total repudiation of life itself.

I thought it had to be misinformation, part of a smear campaign against the organization.

And then I read the chilling words scrawled on a postcard by Ms. Newkirk, speaking ex cathedra as founder of P.E.T.A.. She emphatically states that the organization does not believe that animals hold any intrinsic right to life. And I recoiled. Maybe she feels the same way about humanity. One would definitely have to broach such a philosophical argument to even examine the proposition vis-a-vis animals. One would need to cross-check any human right to life in the same disquisition.

If you think wild cats can't handle wild living, then how the hell do you think they managed to survive down the ages? If you're helping terminal cats, animals which could not be saved by veterinary intervention, that's a different matter. But again and again we see P.E.T.A. killing healthy cats and even kittens.

It's just more proof that there is no safe harbor in this world. It's just more proof that the world is insane. Even those of whom you expect the highest, the greatest compassion, turn out to be totally mad. Everybody wants to rule the world. You can see this "euthanasia" is really just another manifestation of that. The will to power. It's not loving compassion. It's a power trip. 

Life belongs to life, not to us.

The existential state of wild animals is indeed, quite often, horrible. But do we have a right to end it for no reason? In this pointless killing, P.E.TA. cannot even avail itself of any utilitarian arguments or "game management" arguments as hunters eating the animals they kill may do.

How can P.E.T.A. call itself a shelter (legally)?

"According to PETA, animals want to die (because they 'might suffer' in the future) and killing them is, in Newkirk’s own words, a 'gift.'"

This is not how we honor existence, Ms. Newkirk. WE GIVE LIFE A CHANCE.

I had once called this woman a hero of mine. This side of her personality just makes me realize the world is, indeed, mad.

One can be a nihilist. That's a personal choice. But one should keep it to oneself. One's nihilism should not accrue a body count of thousands of living, sentient creatures. If you follow Newkirk's logic, there's absolutely no problem with killing humans born into poorer countries who will most likely "suffer."

The Death Cult of P.E.T.A.

So, I'm revoking hero status for Newkirk and conferring it instead on "no kill" Nathan J. Winograd.

If you hear someone saying lawyers are no-goodniks, please refer them to Nathan's bio notes.


Friday, June 10, 2016

Philosopher Peter Singer on "The Ethics of What We Eat"

\\

Postscript: California's Proposition 2 did pass and became the Standard for Confining Farm Animals Initiative. How often California leads the way. Step by step progress is being made. But it took seven years for this to be implemented. It went into full effect in 2015. Now how do we get this to be a national standard? So far it's a slow struggle state by state.

Many of these cruel farming practices are also increasing human disease. Bird flu is almost certainly the product of this. And now we are entering an era when we may actually lose the ability to use antibiotics to combat disease. Guess how we got the MCR-1 resistance gene. If you guessed "agricultural abuse of antibiotics in farm animals", you guessed correctly.

Thursday, June 9, 2016

Animal Grief

It's fairly obvious that it is very self-serving for humans to deny animals the possibility of "higher emotions" like grief.

And yet there is so much evidence that higher animals often do grieve. Not all of this is evidence is anecdotal. There have been controlled studies looking at the reactions of pets after the loss of their caregivers or companion animals. There were often signs of bereavement. The data showed this type of behavior was common. Pets often exhibited the same types of behavior grieving humans do; for example, they exhibited lessened appetite, slept more, refused to play, engaged in avoidance behavior, etc.

And yet many people seek to justify and perpetuate this inaccurate view of animals as pure automatons, to deny the possibility of an animal consciousness that might be able to symbolize reality to itself in the ways that we do with our various languages. A quintessential example of this ungenerous and,I think, unconvincing argument can be found in Alfred Russel Wallace's 1889 book Darwinism: “In the first place, we must remember that animals are entirely spared the pain we suffer in the anticipation of death—a pain far greater, in most cases, than the reality. This leads, probably, to an almost perpetual enjoyment of their lives; since their constant watchfulness against danger, and even their actual flight from an enemy, will be the enjoyable exercise of the powers and faculties they possess, unmixed with any serious dread."

This whole scenario espoused by Wallace is meant to be exculpatory: "Don't worry about the animals or their feelings." The animals live in a giddy and blank happiness. How could Wallace believe that there is not great stress in the struggle for survival, especially for those higher animals which are potential prey? And that paragraph conveniently omits any discussion of how physical pain, obviously experienced by all animals, might shade into mental anguish. If consciousness can perceive experience as duration, an interior state that endures, cannot pain be experienced as mental anguish?  Wallace's naivete (or disingenuousness) is ridiculous science. It's not science at all, since there is no evidence to back up this viewpoint, for we have no way (then or now) to observe the interiority of animal mental processes. We can only attempt to intuit this from their behavior. I don't see animals in the Pollyanna way Wallace did. I think there is ample evidence that higher animals can suffer in consciousness as well as body, just as we do, and often for the same reasons. I think there is ample evidence that the higher animals can even experience mental anguish. Life is a continuum. It seems counterintuitive to believe that consciousness itself is not also a continuum or that animals are not on that continuum of consciousness (developed mental processes including the apperception of one's own emotions) with us. We species certainly vary in the degree to which we can think abstractly. But I see much evidence that many higher animals do exhibit an ability to think abstractly to varying degrees and to generalize from memory. But it's so clearly in our "species interest" to continue to treat so many of these sentient species as food or product fodder only and to refuse to attempt to empathize with their own existential plights, which are not all that different from ours.

Wednesday, June 8, 2016

Help End the Yulin Torture "Festival"

Info on Twitter.

You can donate to help the rescue mission here.

There are absolutely horrible videos online showing the torture of caged dogs and cats who are clearly aware of what is happening around them and to them as they are picked off and slaughtered in the most inhumane ways imaginable (beaten to death with blunt instruments).

I just donated.

Here is the petition to end the torture in Yulin.